The enduring magic of Swan Lake


WHEN I asked Google how Swan Lake ends, its AI responded: “Swan Lake has two common endings: a tragic ending where Siegfried and Odette drown themselves to escape the curse, and a ‘happily ever after’ ending where Siegfried defeats the evil sorcerer Von Rothbart, breaking the curse and freeing them to be together. In the tragic version, their love is so strong that their deaths break the spell, allowing them to be united in the afterlife.”

I thought this was just another hallucination but it mostly true, and various interpretation have abounded over the centuries. Composed by Russian composer Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky in 1875–76, and first performed in 1877 by the Bolshoi Ballet, Swan Lake has been through A Lot. It wasn’t even that popular at first, and widely drew negative criticism. Tchaikovsky’s own brother, Modest, said, “The poverty of the production, meaning the décor and costumes, the absence of outstanding performers, the Balletmaster’s weakness of imagination, and, finally, the orchestra … all of this together permitted (Tchaikovsky) with good reason to cast the blame for the failure on others.” The Wikipedia page is quite a ride.

Whatever has been said about it, Swan Lake remains my all-time favourite classical ballet, for various reasons. This weekend we saw it at the CTICC (new, interesting, small stage…). This run saw South Africa’s two leading classical ballet companies join forces to present one of the great ballet classics on a national tour. Cape Town City Ballet and Joburg Ballet performed in Johannesburg and Cape Town this July, bringing together the dancers of both companies to present one of the world’s most famous ballets.

Having done an interview with guest principal dancer Jerome Barnes (Siegfried – look, I’m going assume you know the story and characters), and having heard high praise for his expressive style, I was keen to see him in the role, alongside Hannah Ward as Odette/Odile. I’m so glad I got the chance. Barnes is everything that was promised, and Ward, well she is just exquisite. Once she came on stage, everything else faded into the background. All the pirouettes and big lifts deliver the drama, and if this is the first ballet you see, you will forever judge all others on this baseline.

At the outset, four acts and two intervals seems daunting, but the hours flew by. The limitations of a smaller stage could be felt however; Barnes and Ward often seemed like they needed—deserved—more space (see “pirouettes” above, which use every available square centimetre). Projection designer Kirsti Cumming transformed the setting into a glowing dreamscape with flats and scenic visuals, very clever, very modern.

Following the penultimate performance on Saturday past, Barnes said: “The ballet last night was absolutely stunning. The [Cape Town Philharmonic] orchestra, right through to the audience, and ourselves the dancers, just entwined with each other to create this magical piece called Swan Lake. It was a standing ovation. I just feel overwhelmed with feelings and emotions, and what an experience to be up there dancing for Cape Town.”

Oh, and we got the happily ever after ending.

This production was made possible by Primedia Broadcasting, The Christian Ludolph Marais Trust, and City of Cape Town.

PHOTO CREDIT: Oscar O’Ryan

Bianca Coleman Avatar
Secret Link