AGATHA CHRISTIE was well known for the use of poison in her murder mysteries; out of 66, it was the cause of death for more than 30 characters. “Her familiarity with lethal substances was rooted in real-life experience. Christie…volunteered as a nurse during World War I and was stationed in a hospital dispensary after passing an exam to qualify as an apothecary’s assistant. Prescriptions were prepared by hand in those days, so Christie became intimately familiar with the dosages of a variety of drugs — and their toxic effects,” according to this TIME article.

And so it comes to pass that poison is the murder weapon in Black Coffee, presented by Pieter Toerien at Theatre On The Bay, until April 26. It’s directed by Alan Swerdlow, and stars the incomparable Alan Committie as the Belgian detective Monsieur Hercule Poirot. In this role, transformed from head (literally) to toe, Committie owns the stage as he unravels the identity of the killer, and is as always a delight to watch. He has many to choose from – it’s a very “busy” play with seven possible suspects, if you want to include the butler. Red herrings abound and during the course of three acts, audience members will have plenty of opportunities to see if they can outguess Poirot as he untangles family feuds, old flames and suspicious guests. Just for extra fun, one side plot includes a missing/stolen formula for a new atomic weapon, and another, a notorious spy.
While the business of catching a killer is a serious one, there are humorous aspects as well, such as Captain Arthur Hastings O.B.E. (Ashley Dowds) and the flirtatious Barbara Amory (Dianne Simpson). Aunt Caroline Amory (Anne Williams), sister of the victim, brings lightness in her non-stop chatter and apparent oblivion to what is going on at any given time. Committie has his best comedic moment right near the end…

Toerien previously presented Black Coffee at The Baxter Theatre from 13 December 1984 to 5 January 1985, directed by Rex Garner, and starring Bill Flynn as Poirot. The play toured to Cape Town, Johannesburg, Port Elizabeth, and Durban. Christie’s works – books and plays – are considered classics but one does need to take into account they are from a different time (Black Coffee premiered at the Embassy Theatre in London in December 1930, so that’s a fair understatement), and follow a certain formula. If you can manage your expectations thus, you’ll be in for a fun night at the theatre.
- Black Coffee runs at Theatre On The Bay until 26 April, before transferring to Pieter Toerien’s Montecasino Theatre from 30 April until 1 June, 2025.
- Tickets: R180 – R300
- Duration: Approximately 150 minutes, including a 20-minute interval
- Age restriction: None, however the play deals with themes of murder, crime, and potentially violence, which might not be suitable for younger audiences
- Book here or call Theatre On The Bay box office on 021 438 3301. For group bookings, email reception@theatreonthebay.co.za
PHOTO CREDIT: Claude Barnardo

