SA wine quality still on the up, says Tim Atkin MW 

Best Value Red of the Year - 2020 Alto Rouge

INTERNATIONAL wine critic and commentator Tim Atkin MW is upbeat about the South African wine industry and says it is “producing the greatest wines in its history” despite the prevailing economic and structural setbacks faced by many.  The reasons, he believes, are: “Better viticulture and site-selection, superior virus-free plant material and a broader palette of grape varieties.”

In his just-released 319-page 2023 South Africa Report, now in its 11th annual edition, he contends the country’s whites are “some of the best on the planet” and claims “the Cape has eclipsed the Loire Valley as the source of the world’s best dry Chenin Blancs”.  Meanwhile, its reds “are now a match for … its world-class whites”.

Tim Atkin MW

The only wine to gain full marks is a red, the Boschkloof Epilogue Syrah 2021, underscoring his confidence in South Africa’s expression of this Rhône grape. Two reds crack 99 points. They are the Le Riche Cabernet Sauvignon Reserve 2020 and the Porseleinberg Syrah 2021. Atkin notes: “acidity rather than sugar levels is the current focus, backbone and spinal cord” of what he describes as the country’s “New Wave reds”.

The highest score of 99 points for a white wine, goes to Alheit Vineyards Huilkrans 2022, a single-origin Chenin Blanc. Cap Classiques, with their distinctively South African profile, Atkin finds “increasingly impressive”. He is also optimistic about the growing foreign investment in the winelands, for the expertise it brings to local viticulture and winemaking, as well as to global brand building.

Atkin acknowledges decline in the national vineyard that has shrunk from a peak of just over 102 000 hectares in 2006 to the present 89 400 hectares, but also points to its increasing diversity. There are around 110 wine grape varieties currently under cultivation, with South Africa’s vines growing “in the oldest viticultural soils in the world”.

Overall Rosé of the Year – 2022 Lievland Liefkoos Rosé

He highlights the extent to which terroir is increasingly defining South Africa’s best wines. While there is “more and more focus on the best areas for individual varieties and wine styles”, he believes the industry could benefit from “greater precision” in demarcation. There should be greater official accent placed on sub-regions, he asserts. This could accelerate the country’s focus on site-specific and soil-specific wines. He praises the increasing emphasis on soil health and regenerative viticultural practices among local growers. This is an rising necessity as more marked variations in vintage take hold, the result of climate change, with the occurrence of more random weather events and rising temperatures.

Atkin welcomes how climate change challenges are being addressed by leading viticulturists like Rosa Kruger. She advocates for “planting smarter” by cultivating higher and cooler, choosing varieties with higher levels of natural acidity, working with the contours of the land to channel rainwater and fight erosion and promoting intra-vineyard biodiversity. Kruger’s work is being supported by initiatives within academia and industry bodies to explore “different grapes, clones, rootstocks, trellising systems, cover crops and ploughing techniques”. These varieties include Assyrtiko, Carignan, Roussanne, Tinta Barroca and Vermentino.

Overall Sweet Wine of the Year – 2022 Mullineux Straw Wine

He commends Eben Sadie and others like him for looking to Croatia, Greece, Italy, Portugal, Spain and North Africa for climate-appropriate varieties. At the same time, improved access to more detailed data is allowing growers to consider Wemmershoek in the Western Cape and the Winterberg and Amatola Mountains in the Eastern Cape as potential new wine-growing areas.

Once again, “Chenin makes a disproportionate number of South Africa’s top whites” either alone or in Mediterranean blends. He scores 29 Chenins 95 points or higher. Chardonnay is the second most successful variety, with 20 wines earning 95 points or more.

Atkin anoints Marelise Niemann of Momento Wines in Bot River as new Young Winemaker of the Year. She has been making wine for most of her professional life in Bot River. Since establishing her own label in 2013, her focus has been on Grenache (Noir, Gris and Blanc), and a small range of other Mediterranean, climate-resilient varieties well able to cope with heat and relatively low rainfall.

The title of Winemaker of the Year goes to Bruwer Raats of Raats Family Wines of Polkadraai Hills, Stellenbosch. He was an early champion of Cabernet Franc and old-vine Chenin Blanc, and has now established international renown for these varieties, as well as his icon wine MR de Compostella. As Viticulturist of the Year, Willie Mostert is honoured for his work in the Voor-Paardeberg ward of Paarl. For the past 20 years he has been encouraging producers to preserve old vines where possible and when planting anew, to cultivate Mediterranean varietals, so well-suited to the location.

Sparkling Wine Discovery of the Year – 2009 Graham Beck Artisan Collection Extra Brut 157

Daschbosch in the Breedekloof district is Co-operative of the Year and Etienne Le Riche, founder of the eponymous Le Riche Wines at the foothills of the Helderberg in Stellenbosch, is this year’s Winemaking Legend, celebrated for his family winery’s varied Cabernet Sauvignons, made alongside his son Christo.

The podium of top achievers includes many regular winners from Alheit to Boplaas, Graham Beck, KWV, Lievland, Mullineux, Rall Wines and Sadie Family Wines, representing a healthy mix of newer-generation and old-timers.


  • Winemaker of the Year: Bruwer Raats of Raats Family Wines
  • Young Winemaker of the Year: Marelise Niemann of Momento
  • Viticulturist of the Year: Willie Mostert
  • Co-operative of the Year: Daschbosch
  • Winemaking Legend: Etienne Le Riche
  • Best Cellar Door Experience: Blaauwklippen Vineyards
  • Overall White Wine of the Year: 2022 Alheit Vineyards Huilkrans Chenin Blanc, Citrusdal Mountain
  • Overall Red Wine of the Year: 2021 Boschkloof Epilogue Syrah, Stellenbosch
  • Overall Rosé of the Year: 2022 Lievland Liefkoos Rosé, Stellenbosch
  • Overall Sparkling Wine of the Year: 2018 Graham Beck Cuvée Clive, Western Cape
  • Overall Sweet Wine of the Year: 2022 Mullineux Straw Wine, Swartland
  • Overall Fortified Wine of the Year: 2007 Boplaas CWG Auction Reserve Tawny Single Harvest Colheita, Calitzdorp
  • Red Wine Discovery of the Year: 2021 Rall CWG Noa Syrah, Swartland
  • White Wine Discovery of the Year: 2022 Sadie Family Rotsbank, Swartland
  • Sparkling Wine Discovery of the Year: 2009 Graham Beck Artisan Collection Extra Brut 157, Western Cape
  • Best Value White of the Year: 2021 Windmeul Cellar OVP Reserve Chenin Blanc, Paarl
  • Best Value Red of the Year: 2020 Alto Rouge, Stellenbosch
  • Best Value Rosé of the Year: 2022 Noble Hill Mourvèdre Rosé, Simonsberg-Paarl
  • Best Value Sparkling Wine of the Year: NV KWV Laborie Brut, Western Cape
  • Best Value Sweet Wine of the Year: 2023 Van Loveren VRL Special Late Harvest Gewürztraminer, Robertson
  • Best value Fortified Wine of the Year: NV KWV Cape Classic Tawny, Western Cape

To purchase the report, where more detail can be found, click here. For more information about Atkin’s career in wine, click here.

You might also like
Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments