WINTER, glorious winter. It’s not everyone’s favourite season but I don’t know what’s not to love about wrapping up in coats and gloves and scarves to go Outside, or blankets, fluffy slippers and hot chocolate when you’re Inside. Then there’s all the wonderful winter food like soups and stews, and of course winter specials at restaurants all over Cape Town (and your Instagram if you have that sort of feed).
The Luke Dale Roberts Group of restaurants is once again offering its renowned prix fixe menus at all its restaurants until 30 September 2025 (more here). Today we are specifically concerned with The Pot Luck Club, where we had lunch the other day. There are two options (also available in Joburg):
• Prix Fixe Lite: A vibrant six-plate sharing experience for two, ideal for a quick, flavour- packed lunch. Cape Town R550 per person, Johannesburg (The Peech Boutique Hotel) R495 per person.
• Prix Fixe Loaded: A more indulgent eight-plate sharing experience for two, perfect for a lingering, flavour packed dining experience. Cape Town R795 per person lunch only, Johannesburg R795 per person lunch and dinner. Wine pairing can be added for R595 per person.
And even more specifically, I’m going to tell you more about the Loaded menu, because that’s what we had, plus a few other dishes that executive chef Jason Kosmas (pictured above) sent out to spoil us. I couldn’t keep track of it all but I hung on to the menu so let’s go through that. The pics here were supplied, but I’ll post mine on Instagram.
First up is rye sourdough country loaf with cultured butter, PLC marinated olives, confit garlic and cashew nut dukkah, plus a delicious morsel they call Taco 2.0 – line fish ceviche, black bean purée, charred corn salsa, avocado and chipotle dressing. The wine with these is Saurwein Chi Riesling 2024. If you’ve not yet tasted Jessica Saurwein’s Rieslings from the Elgin valley, I recommend you do: fragrant citrus blossom, yellow flowers and citrus, white pear, ginger, flint… “chi” means “life force” and stands for Chiuta (an African rain god). I’m not clever; I looked that up on the website.

Next up is Springfield Albariño 2024paired with sashimi with citrus salad, pickled kombucha, fragrant herbs, dashi pearls, hibiscus and sesame dressing, Such a pretty plate. The famous PLC fish sliders follow – hake, mojo dressing and miso mayo – with Kumusha white blend 2022, the label founded by Zimbabwean one-time sommelier Tinashe Nyamudoka. Read a profile on him here. It looks a bit old but you’ll get the idea.
Moving along, there is pork belly Penang in coconut and peanut curry, with lime-pickled red onions and coriander oil, and two wine options: Bellevue Reserve Chenin 2021 (anything with “reserve” in its name is going to be good) or Chamonix Pinot Noir 2023. The smoked beef fillet with black pepper and truffle café au lait is legendary. I didn’t take a pic of it (the professional one below is much better) but I did run my finger (and then a spoon) through the leftover sauce because it should be bottled to take home. It’s served with another PLC staple, chickpea, goat’s cheese and parmesan fries with truffle aioli and smoked ketchup. Best eaten as hot as you can handle, these are so moreish. The wine is Weather Report Cab Franc 2021.
Onto the sweet stuff: there is a choice for dessert, but we were offered both. I just can’t with sago and the “bits” in it so I didn’t even try that. Childhood food trauma, you know? I was also mildly horrified to see an Instagram reel recently that sang the praises of scrambled eggs with chopped tomato aka Spanish scrambled eggs, which my granny used to make (her mother was Spanish) and I loathed. Even watching the reel was triggering. However, the peanut butter bomb was a sheer delight of textures and flavour. I passed on the dessert wine, too sweet for me, no matter what they say to try to convince me: Joostenberg NHL Chenin Blanc. As is the wont with restaurants like PLC, just when you think you’ve had the last of it and can’t manage another mouthful, they come with the plate of sweets. Nothing wrong with that, just be prepared.
Bottom line, this is a spectacular feast of flavours, with dishes all beautifully balanced from beginning to end. As for the view, it’s breathtaking. The new parking system at the Old Biscuit Mill involves your car’s registration number so make sure you know it before approaching the pay station. I am that person who has never memorised hers so I had to traipse back and take a pic with my phone. Will I learn my lesson? Unlikely.
See all the menus and booking details here.

