NEWLY opened this winter, Mill St Bistro – an ode to French bistronomy – is the culmination of a lifelong dream for Welsh chef Phil Carmichael.
This is where we had a delightful late lunch during an all-too-short stay in Stellenbosch. It may have been brief but it was filled with wonderful wine, stories, art, great company and of course, delicious food. With all the new and new-ish places that have opened here, Stellies is claiming its place as the culinary capital of the Cape.
“At the peak of his career when the pandemic hit, and with three children under five, Carmichael strapped on his knapsack and with his wife and young family, flew to South Africa to follow his dream of making incredible food that is healthier and more sustainable,” the press release tells us.
“Reconnecting with old friend and Spier resident organic regenerative farmer Angus McIntosh, he spent a year running the vineyard’s food offerings. Finally, after months of searching, he found the perfect location and Mill St Bistro was born.
“Carmichael’s approach to dining, like the man himself, is entirely fuss-free. Dishes are simple – deceptively so – with hidden layers of depth and an underlying wholesomeness that somehow only adds to the experience. This is what Mill St Bistro is really all about for Carmichael: taking classical French bistronomy, and marrying it with his passions, leaving the diner with a renewed sense of comfort, soulfulness, and wholesomeness.”
Bordering on mid-afternoon, the restaurant was quiet so Carmichael had time to chat to us about his food, which are the kind of things he himself likes to eat. He’s into fermenting and shelves and countertops are dotted with jars of works in progress. I had the tender and succulent pork belly which is wood fired in the oven inherited with the premises, and served with pickled apple and chilli ketchup, tangy house-fermented sauerkraut to balance the rich meat, and a generous sheet of crackling. My friend let Carmichael choose for her and she got the “day boat market” fish (from Abalobi, an organisation which I ardently support) with sweetcorn, mussel and ginger succotash, baby marrow and nasturtium pesto, a colourful dish crammed with all those veggies (pictured below).
“Everything we put in the succotash is from Somerset West Community Garden, which is two minutes from my house. I go down there, select what I want, they pick it, and it’s in the restaurant the next day,” says Carmichael.
Nasturtiums are quite amazing; they grow everywhere, like weeds, in any conditions. You only need to throw those seeds on the ground once and you’ll have them coming up every year. They don’t even care if you water them or not. I know this because I have that situation in my own garden. They’re an ingredient championed by Mill St’s kitchen. “The flowers in the nasturtium pesto are actually from my garden,” says Carmichael. “We also use them to make a beautiful crazy bright orange vinegar, nasturtium flower kombucha, pesto with the green leaves, and nasturtium capers with the seed pods, which we’ll use throughout the winter as garnishes on fish dishes and whatnot.”
For starters I had yellowtail tartare with pickled daikon, cucumber, mascarpone and lime dressing, toasted macadamia nuts, with romaine lettuce leaves to scoop it up. Gorgeous flavours, but my friend’s mushroom parfait with marinated mushroom salad, pickled mustard seeds and shallots, with herb flatbread, won Dish Of The Day hands down. It’s the dish you will go there especially for, just that and a glass of wine from the superb list, perhaps on the deck while people-watching. In fact, can we not normalise (since it’s trendy to normalise all sorts of things these days) going to a restaurant for one thing? A starter here, perhaps another starter somewhere else (there is no rule I know of that says “small plates” have to be eaten in the same place), maybe a main, maybe not. An ice cream parlour for dessert. A glass of wine where the urge takes you…
Our desserts were two specials which could find their way onto the permanent menu. Mine will only be around for a short while though: a cherry and almond cake with cherry vanilla ice cream. I’ll post that on Instagram, along with the oh-so-pretty mini peach trifle. I think the pics will speak for themselves. It was nothing less than pure greediness and temptation that a bowl of warm malva madeleines with miso butterscotch arrived at the table too.
Everything is served on hand-crafted ceramics from award-winning ceramicist Mervin Gers, something I’m always thrilled to spot in the wild, being the fan of his work that I am. People who dine with me are used to me lifting up plates to look underneath, more for confirmation than anything else, so I can smile and nod approvingly.
Be sure to put Mill St Bistro on your To Do list next time you’re in Stellenbosch. For more information and online bookings, click here or email bookings@millstbistro.co.za
Follow Mill St Bistro’s story via: IG @millstbistro

